September 3, 2008
By this everyone will know that
you are my disciples, if you have love
for one another.
- John 13:35
I have appreciated the thoughtful emails, phone calls and conversations with many of you regarding the topics addressed in our current sermon series, "Faith and Politics." One of the ways I brag about you as a congregation is that you are a group of people who love to learn, are interested in ideas, and know how to listen to others’ opinions, and to continue in relationship with one another in spite of deep disagreements over various issues of theology and politics.
It takes energy, patience and perseverance to listen with the intention of really understanding the other’s point of view. We are often tempted to interrupt someone whose point of view seems outrageous to us. Other times we are tempted to simply wait silently until we can defend our own positions. Sometimes it is comforting and reassuring just to hang out with others who largely reinforce our existing opinions. But if that is all we ever do, we really do ourselves a big disservice. When we converse with others who believe and think differently, we are often able to see the flaws and limitations in our own arguments. We become aware of the complexities, subtleties and nuances that are often required in our endeavors.
This is not to say that we should adopt the goal of changing others or that we will change our basic position. However, when we converse respectfully with those whose ideas diff er from our own, we do better thinking! When Christians have conversations like this in a spirit of generosity, we are practicing the best of agape love and making a positive witness for Christ.
A few members have told me that they are refraining from public worship during part or all of the series. In all cases, people have affirmed their regard for me and for the congregation. I’m guessing
that there are others who are doing the same who haven’t talked to me about it. Some people have wanted to avoid particular subjects. Others believe that "Faith and Politics" should never be in the same sentence and that it is a deep violation of the concept of "separation of church
and state." One person said that church should be about spiritual things and not political things.
I encouraged people in this latter category to listen to the introductory sermon about how we are defining the terms "faith" and "politics." We are using a Harold Laswell definition that says politics is the process of deciding who gets what, when and how. Thus politics is
about power and justice which are very much concerns of the scriptures and woven through Jesus’ teaching. For example, we might disagree about how to implement care for the poor, but caring for the poor is at heart a political process which, for Christians, is informed by our faith as disciples of Jesus.
In the sermon on "The Definition of Marriage," I described several theological perspectives that Christians have in response to Proposition 8. One perspective included a high value for the separation of church and state. But I didn’t go into detail about where we derived the
concept. That question was raised in the panel discussion on the following Wednesday evening. Two panelists, one on each side of the issue, affirmed agreement on this topic and reminded us that the U.S. Constitution never uses the phrase. Rather, the first amendment says, "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…"
The phrase in question is generally traced to an 1802 letter from Thomas Jefferson to a Baptist leader in Danbury, Connecticut in which Jefferson said that the first amendment created a wall of separation between church and state. Of course, many citizens were coming from countries in which there was a state-sponsored religion and in which they had experienced exclusion and persecution just for being part of a diff erent denomination (same religion) from the one sponsored by the state. The amendment was meant to protect the people from the state, not the state from the people! Yet we do need caution to ensure that as we infuse our political decisions with the values of our faith perspective that we are not infringing on others’ constitutional rights.
We have some complex matters before us and I have very much appreciated the opportunity to discuss them with my brothers and sisters in Christ from the perspective of our shared values. I have appreciated the opportunity to bring these matters before God as a community and to ask for wisdom as we discern together how best to respond. Once again, I have been impressed with you and the ways we
are modeling our faith for the larger community. Keep praying!
Walking with you as we follow Jesus,
Debra

